| 2009 Season |
| Sat., Sept. 5 |
Wartburg College (Football Alumni Day) |
W 42-35/OT |
1-0 |
| Sat., Sept. 12 |
at Grinnell College * |
W 14-11 |
2-0 |
| Sat., Sept. 19 |
Lawrence Univ. * (Family Weekend/Hall of Fame Day) |
W 45-3 |
3-0 |
| Sat., Sept. 26 |
at Lake Forest College * |
W 35-14 |
4-0 |
| Sat., Oct. 3 |
Knox College * |
W 56-13 |
5-0 |
| Sat., Oct. 10 |
at Monmouth College * |
L 52-24 |
5-1 |
| Sat., Oct. 17 |
at Carroll Univ. * |
W 28-20 |
6-1 |
| Sat., Oct. 24 |
Ripon College * (Homecoming) |
W 41-28 |
7-1 |
| Sat., Oct. 31 |
Beloit College * |
W 44-0 |
8-1 |
| Sat., Nov. 7 |
at Illinois College * |
W 49-0 |
9-1 |
